Price Satisfaction

Discover whether pet owners feel they’re getting good value from their pet insurance plans. These reviews focus on pricing transparency, affordability, and overall satisfaction with plan costs.

20,691 total


December 24, 2025

Protection for our four legged little friends

Unlike the experience I’ve had with some of these aftermarket car warranties Pets Best insurance has done exactly as they have described to do they take care of me when they need to and then there’s sometimes I’ll turn a claim in that they can’t pay on and that’s fine but they’ve been fair all along. I just filled a claim and was reimbursed nearly 3months dues with very little out of pocket. I think and while I don’t wish harm to anyone’s 4-legged little friend, hospital bills is where the real magic happens in terms of reimbursements.

Insurer: Pets Best

By: David Goodbary

Verified December 24, 2025

Great

Great, best deal I’ve found for my furbabies and love being able to customize for the coverages I need and the remove the ones I don’t covered with to help with premium!

Insurer: Nationwide

By: Amy Stewart

Verified December 24, 2025

Great service and we were reimbursed a…

Great service and we were reimbursed a good amount!

Insurer: Fetch

By: Whitney Call

Verified December 24, 2025

It was easy to sign up for my pets…

It was easy to sign up for my pets insurance through my work place. I received my quote right away and the information was clear.

Insurer: Nationwide

By: Dania

Verified December 24, 2025

Fast Response

I've been with MetLife for almost 3.5 Yrs. Even though they maybe pricier than some competitors, it will make up on what they have to offer. They give you option on what is best suited for your Fur Baby.

Insurer: MetLife

By: Quiana Brown

December 24, 2025

Take others' negative experiences seriously - find another pet insurance provider.

Guys - don't ignore the red flags/warning signs. Embrace Pet Insurance is as close to being a scam as it gets while still remaining legal. Do not fall for the marketing. Choose a different pet insurance provider! Read the other 1-star reviews - there's a common thread. People pay premiums for years while their pet is healthy, then the moment they need anything from Embrace, they're made to submit copious paperwork, which Embrace's claims agents then go through with a magnifying glass, broadly creating new diagnoses based on small remarks, like "scratched his ear" - oh, all ear infections are now and forevermore pre-existing. "Hind leg looks stiff" - now we will never cover any joint-related issues in any leg. When I talked to my vet about how insane all of this was, he asked me who my pet insurance was, and when I said Embrace, he rolled his eyes and told me to give up and switch, because he's had previous negative experiences trying to appeal denials with Embrace. You can actually get a sample of the type of treatment you will get by reading their replies to these reviews. Even in their replies to Trustpilot reviews, they use carefully crafted legalese - using many words to justify denied claims that, under normal common sense, should be covered. I've learned my lesson the hard way, cancelled my policy, and accepted that the premiums I've paid are gone forever. But if I can help you avoid the stress and frustration that comes with realizing that all the money you've put into Embrace for a peace of mind was for naught at precisely the moment you are most worried sick for your pet, then at least the money had some use after all.

Insurer: Embrace

By: George

Verified December 24, 2025

This pet insurance is better than…

This pet insurance is better than others because of how it pays back costs, the amount it pays back, and the deductible. The online claim is easy to use, and processing happens very fast.

Insurer: MetLife

By: Dr. Verdell Marsh

December 24, 2025

Would Not Recommend

I've had insurance coverage with Pumpkin for almost a year, and while the policy looks comprehensive on paper, my actual experience has been frustrating and extremely disappointing. My biggest issue has been Pumpkin’s denial of a claim for what they labeled a “pre-existing condition.” My dog was seen by her veterinarian for a respiratory issue and underwent diagnostic testing to determine the cause. Although she had experienced a similar respiratory issue in the past, that issue had fully resolved on its own. According to my policy, any condition that has been cured and free of symptoms or treatment for 180 days should not be considered pre-existing, and my dog clearly met that requirement. Despite this, Pumpkin denied the claim. I was told I could appeal the decision and that my veterinarian could clarify in the medical records that the prior respiratory issue had resolved. I did exactly that and submitted an appeal with updated clinic notes. The appeal was denied anyway. Pumpkin completely ignored both my explanation and my vet’s updated notes and continued to rely on outdated records. I attempted to submit a second appeal, which Pumpkin initially refused to accept. At that point, I contacted the California Department of Insurance for assistance. This prompted Pumpkin to conduct a third review, but the outcome was the same. Once again, they ignored the facts, my statements, and my veterinarian’s updated clinical notes, and continued to deny the claim based on the same old information. This entire process was exhausting, stressful, and incredibly discouraging. It has left me worried that my dog will not receive the coverage she needs if other health issues arise in the future. My second major issue is the outrageous renewal increase. My premium is going up by 59%. This kind of increase is unreasonable—especially when Pumpkin has already shown they are unwilling to cover significant health issues. At this point, I am seriously questioning whether it’s worth continuing my policy with them. Overall, I am extremely dissatisfied and would not consider myself a happy customer.

Insurer: Pumpkin

By: Theresa R

Verified December 23, 2025

MetLife absolutely has the best…

MetLife absolutely has the best coverage in the market right now for your pets. Over the past two years since I’ve had them, their reimbursement has been a little slow, but reasonable. Recently they have been super fast – the last three claims I submitted were all paid in under a week! I couldn’t be happier with this company.

Insurer: MetLife

By: Jean Hall

Verified December 23, 2025

good service good prices

good service good prices

Insurer: MetLife

By: Enrique Torres

Compare top pet insurance providers plans.