209,630+ Pet Insurance Reviews You Can Trust
Pet parents across the U.S. and Canada have left over 209,630 verified reviews—real stories, real experiences, real insight. Whether you're after the best price, fastest claims, or friendliest service, our reviews make it easy to compare top insurance providers and find the perfect coverage for your pets.
209,630 total
What are you looking for?
Most selected providers in "March, 2026"
This chart shows the distribution of the most selected pet insurance providers in March, 2026.
Providers with highest rating
19,735 reviews
11,015 reviews
5,290 reviews
55,032 reviews
8,866 reviews
Category with most reviews
This chart shows the distribution of review categories.
Prudent Pet Insurance accepted my 18yo cat with a reasonable premium.
I was with Nationwide Pet Insurance for about 8 years before they increased my premium by 6x due to my cat turning 18yo. I searched around a lot. There aren't many pet insurance providers that will insure an 18yo cat, but Prudent Pet Insurance did! I found a plan w/ a reasonable premium and great coverage. My cat's health took a quick turn for the worse. I have spoken on the phone and emailed with Jenna and Delaney multiple times as they provided me with friendly and empathetic service. Claims were reviewed, settled, and paid quickly. I'm satisfied with my choice to go with Prudent Pet Insurance.
Insurer: Prudent Pet
By: Melissa Rivera
Pumpkin was wonderful to work with
One of our dogs had to have a major surgery this past year. Pumpkin was wonderful to work. They communicated well and always reimbursed me for covered medical expenses in a timely manner. I will always have Pumpkin Insurance for my pets.
Insurer: Pumpkin
By: Debbie
Terrible when you need them.
Terrible when you need them. I was with them for 7 years, and they can cancel you without giving options, leaving you stranded when you need them most. They will say whatever you want to hear to sign you up—don't fall for it. Poor customer service; they don't care. You've been warned.
Insurer: Healthy Paws
By: Moses D
The agent that I was speaking to was…
The agent that I was speaking to was great. Polite, very helpful and patient.
Insurer: Embrace
By: Alan Rooks
Embrace is quick and easy to file a…
Embrace is quick and easy to file a claim (under 5 minutes) and quick to reimburse on direct deposit! They truly care!
Insurer: Embrace
By: Pam Backofen
Claims are processed very slow and the…
Claims are processed very slow and the monthly charge is way too much
Insurer: Pets Best
By: John Costello
Denied routine care in spite of yearly allowance.
I purchased this insurance through Progressive for my cat and made sure to get a plan that covered teeth cleanings. It came time to bring my cat in for a teeth cleaning, and the vet found brand new dental issues (tooth re-absorption) that required extractions as they are quite painful for cats. The bill ended up being quite expensive surprise. When I submitted it to ManyPets, they denied everything, including the cleaning that my plan explictly covers $150/year for, on the grounds that my cat had evidence of gingivitis (what cat doesn't) so therefore the brand new tooth reabsorption was a pre-existing condition. My vet put together a very well evidenced rebuttal proving that the tooth reabsorption was a new issue, unrelated to the gingivitis, that no one had known about (again, this happened during a teeth cleaning visit). ManyPets response was to cover the $150 for the cleaning they initially denied, and nothing else. I do not recommend this insurance and am very frustrated that Progressive recommended it to me. It's one thing to deny claims for frivolous reasons, it's another to deny routine care that do not come with any conditions on the contract. I will be changing providers as soon as my term is up.
Insurer: ManyPets
By: J M
Friendly and informative
Amanda was very friendly and knowledgeable
Insurer: Fetch
By: Gilda