Price Satisfaction

Discover whether pet owners feel they’re getting good value from their pet insurance plans. These reviews focus on pricing transparency, affordability, and overall satisfaction with plan costs.

20,691 total


Verified November 26, 2025

It's expensive but it's worth it

Website is easy to navigate they are quick on paying your claims no hassle You get what you paid for especially if you have a small dog

Insurer: Figo

By: Paul B

November 26, 2025

CRIMINAL & PREDATORY COMPANY

I've had Healthy Paws on two of my dogs since 2014, they're now both over 10 yrs old. The rate hikes are INSANE, we just went from $350/month to almost $1000/month, with LESS coverage. This company is CRIMINAL. I've had FIGO pet insurance for my third dog and she is OLDER than the two that are with Healthy Paws- we pay less than $200/month for her for the EXACT SAME COVERAGE ($250 yearly deductible, no annual/lifetime limit, 90% coverage) and she's 14 yrs old! What the hell is going on? They really get you because now that my dogs are over 10 and have pre-existing conditions, we can't get coverage elsewhere without sacrificing coverage on their pre-existing conditions, so it's either stay with Healthy Paws and pay outrageous premiums or drop the coverage completely. We'll be dropping. Outrageous and criminal. I'm just sick. If you have a young animal and are considering Healthy Paws, know that the rates they start you at are extremely deceiving and if you plan to keep your policy on your pet for it's lifetime, BE VERY PREPARED BECAUSE YOUR RATES WILL SKYROCKET. My advice- STAY AWAY!

Insurer: Healthy Paws

By: Jen

Verified November 26, 2025

Easy to fill out just expensive but has…

Easy to fill out just expensive but has to have it for my dog since I have insurance as well

Insurer: MetLife

By: Mandy

Verified November 25, 2025

I am enjoying my experience with this…

I am enjoying my experience with this pet insurance. Best price.

Insurer: Nationwide

By: customer

November 25, 2025

The app doesn’t work correctly

The app doesn’t work correctly. It doesn’t allow you to type a question or answer a question that the bot asks. The premium is so high that the amounts reimbursed makes it not worth having. It is the biggest regret I’ve ever had with an insurance policy.

Insurer: Fetch

By: Brendan Ortenzi

Verified November 25, 2025

easy and great price

easy and great price. will save me a bundle

Insurer: Prudent Pet

By: Paulie B

Verified November 25, 2025

The plans presented were very easy to…

The plans presented were very easy to understand and website was easy to navigate. Price was excellent value

Insurer: MetLife

By: Debra Lehotsky

Verified November 25, 2025

Fast service

Reimbursement is always fast. I appreciate that most things are covered after deductible is met.

Insurer: MetLife

By: Leo's mom

November 25, 2025

I’m extremely disappointed with Pumpkin…

I’I’m extremely disappointed with Pumpkin Pet Insurance and would not recommend them to other pet owners. I brought my cat to the vet after he threw up one time. My vet performed blood work, monitored him, and cleared him — nothing serious or chronic was found. One time. My cat threw up several times and became dehydrated.  We had to take him to emergency room after seeing his vet to get fluids. Despite this, Pumpkin denied the  entire claim, stating that the issue was considered a pre-existing condition.   This is extremely frustrating because my cat was evaluated by a licensed veterinarian and medically cleared with no ongoing condition, yet Pumpkin still refused coverage. If a single incident of vomiting can be twisted into a reason to deny legitimate care, then what are you really paying for? I get pet insurance for peace of mind, not to fight over basic emergency care when something unexpected happens. Instead of support during a stressful moment with my pet, I was left dealing with paperwork, excuses, and a denial. Save your money and look elsewhere — when it actually matters, they won’t be there for you

Insurer: Pumpkin

By: Christine Sodikoff

November 25, 2025

Fetch insurance is a bad company. Go elsewhere.

We didn’t find much use for this plan so we decided to cancel. My wife went to cancel and thought she did but we still got charged. She called back and they said they need the main policy holder to cancel. But they didn’t tell my wife that when she initially called. They won’t refund us the months that we wanted to cancel and thought we did. Disappointed in the customer service.

Insurer: Fetch

By: Matt

Useful

Compare top pet insurance providers plans.