154,902+ Pet Insurance Reviews You Can Trust
Pet parents across the U.S. and Canada have left over 150,000 verified reviews—real stories, real experiences, real insight. Whether you're after the best price, fastest claims, or friendliest service, our review hub makes it easy to compare top providers and find your perfect match.
331,057 total
What are you looking for?
Most selected providers in "February, 2026"
This chart shows the distribution of the most selected pet insurance providers in February, 2026.
Providers with highest rating
19,677 reviews
10,925 reviews
5,119 reviews
58,897 reviews
14,559 reviews
Category with most reviews
This chart shows the distribution of review categories.
Immediate issue
Immediately after paying I was prompted to register to the portal but was met with a 500 server error even when attempting to log into the site separately.
Insurer: Prudent Pet
By: mary
Immediate issue
Immediately after paying I was prompted to register to the portal but was met with a 500 server error even when attempting to log into the site separately.
Insurer: Prudent Pet
By: mary
Immediate issue
Immediately after paying I was prompted to register to the portal but was met with a 500 server error even when attempting to log into the site separately.
Insurer: Prudent Pet
By: mary
Immediate issue
Immediately after paying I was prompted to register to the portal but was met with a 500 server error even when attempting to log into the site separately.
Insurer: Prudent Pet
By: mary
Was nervous but pumpkin turned out to be awesome
I was dropped by nationwide. And to be honest nationwide had an amazing policy. I also had a dog with pre-existing condition of allergies. I looked and looked and tried to compare all of the different plans available, and I settled on pumpkin because they basically offered the same plan that I had with nationwide. Obviously they couldn’t cover the pre-existing allergy condition, but everything else was the exact same so I opted for the unlimited plan, including emergency and wellness. I have been very happy with pumpkin the turnaround time for payment on claims is so fast and they do estimates so for example if you have a big procedure coming up like a teeth cleaning, I submitted a estimate and was preapproved so by the time we had the procedure and I submitted the bill I had payment deposit deposited into my bank account within 24 hours. They are a great company to work with. I’m pleased that I picked them. I was nervous because I really did have a good experience with nationwide until they dropped me. But pumpkin has been great and I would recommend it to anybody looking for insurance. And I totally recommend the unlimited plan.
Insurer: Pumpkin
By: Jenny
Was nervous but pumpkin turned out to be awesome
I was dropped by nationwide. And to be honest nationwide had an amazing policy. I also had a dog with pre-existing condition of allergies. I looked and looked and tried to compare all of the different plans available, and I settled on pumpkin because they basically offered the same plan that I had with nationwide. Obviously they couldn’t cover the pre-existing allergy condition, but everything else was the exact same so I opted for the unlimited plan, including emergency and wellness. I have been very happy with pumpkin the turnaround time for payment on claims is so fast and they do estimates so for example if you have a big procedure coming up like a teeth cleaning, I submitted a estimate and was preapproved so by the time we had the procedure and I submitted the bill I had payment deposit deposited into my bank account within 24 hours. They are a great company to work with. I’m pleased that I picked them. I was nervous because I really did have a good experience with nationwide until they dropped me. But pumpkin has been great and I would recommend it to anybody looking for insurance. And I totally recommend the unlimited plan.
Insurer: Pumpkin
By: Jenny
Was nervous but pumpkin turned out to be awesome
I was dropped by nationwide. And to be honest nationwide had an amazing policy. I also had a dog with pre-existing condition of allergies. I looked and looked and tried to compare all of the different plans available, and I settled on pumpkin because they basically offered the same plan that I had with nationwide. Obviously they couldn’t cover the pre-existing allergy condition, but everything else was the exact same so I opted for the unlimited plan, including emergency and wellness. I have been very happy with pumpkin the turnaround time for payment on claims is so fast and they do estimates so for example if you have a big procedure coming up like a teeth cleaning, I submitted a estimate and was preapproved so by the time we had the procedure and I submitted the bill I had payment deposit deposited into my bank account within 24 hours. They are a great company to work with. I’m pleased that I picked them. I was nervous because I really did have a good experience with nationwide until they dropped me. But pumpkin has been great and I would recommend it to anybody looking for insurance. And I totally recommend the unlimited plan.
Insurer: Pumpkin
By: Jenny
Was nervous but pumpkin turned out to be awesome
I was dropped by nationwide. And to be honest nationwide had an amazing policy. I also had a dog with pre-existing condition of allergies. I looked and looked and tried to compare all of the different plans available, and I settled on pumpkin because they basically offered the same plan that I had with nationwide. Obviously they couldn’t cover the pre-existing allergy condition, but everything else was the exact same so I opted for the unlimited plan, including emergency and wellness. I have been very happy with pumpkin the turnaround time for payment on claims is so fast and they do estimates so for example if you have a big procedure coming up like a teeth cleaning, I submitted a estimate and was preapproved so by the time we had the procedure and I submitted the bill I had payment deposit deposited into my bank account within 24 hours. They are a great company to work with. I’m pleased that I picked them. I was nervous because I really did have a good experience with nationwide until they dropped me. But pumpkin has been great and I would recommend it to anybody looking for insurance. And I totally recommend the unlimited plan.
Insurer: Pumpkin
By: Jenny
Website is very easy to select your…
Website is very easy to select your options. Pleasant experience.
Insurer: MetLife
By: Brook Garman
Website is very easy to select your…
Website is very easy to select your options. Pleasant experience.
Insurer: MetLife
By: Brook Garman