Pet First Aid Myths That Are Dangerous
Posted: 08/18/2025 | BY: Jenna Bruce | Categories: Cat , Dog , Health problems , Pet care
When your pet gets hurt, your first instinct is to help. That’s natural. But in those stressful moments, it’s easy to turn to quick fixes you’ve heard from friends, seen on social media, or even learned years ago. The trouble is, many of these so-called tips are actually pet first aid myths that can cause more harm than good.
The truth is, pets have different biology, metabolism, and sensitivities than humans. What might seem harmless for you can be dangerous – or even life-threatening for your dog or cat. Knowing how to separate fact from fiction could save your pet from unnecessary pain and speed up their recovery.
Let’s bust some of the most common myths so you can feel confident about what to do (and what not to do) in an emergency.
Myth #1: Hydrogen Peroxide Is Great for Cleaning Pet Wounds
The reality: Hydrogen peroxide might bubble impressively, but it’s not a safe or effective wound cleaner for pets. While it can kill bacteria, it may also harm healthy tissue. Using it on an open wound can:
- Cause stinging, pain, and irritation
- Damage fibroblasts (the cells responsible for healing)
- Delay the healing process
- Potentially raise the risk of infection
A safer option is to gently wash open wounds with mild soap and water. For deep cuts or heavy bleeding, seek veterinary care right away.
Myth #2: Human Painkillers Are Safe for Pets
The reality: Medications like ibuprofen, acetaminophen, and aspirin are toxic to pets, even in small doses. They can cause stomach ulcers, kidney damage, or liver failure.
What to do instead: If your pet is in pain, contact your vet immediately. There are safe, pet-specific pain medications available – but only under veterinary supervision.
Myth #3: If Your Pet Is Choking, Reach In and Pull the Object Out
The reality: It’s tempting to grab whatever you see, but reaching into your pet’s throat can push the object deeper or injure their airway. In some cases, you could be bitten if your pet is panicking.
What to do instead: If your pet is truly choking and unable to breathe, use pet-specific first aid techniques like the Heimlich maneuver for dogs or back blows for cats. Then get to the vet immediately. If your pet is still able to breathe, it’s safer to let a vet remove the object.
Myth #4: Inducing Vomiting Is Always the Right Move After Ingestion
The reality: While inducing vomiting can be helpful in certain poisoning cases, it’s not safe for all substances. For example, if your pet swallows something caustic (like bleach) or oily (like gasoline), vomiting can cause more damage.
What to do instead: Call your vet or a pet poison control hotline before taking action. They can guide you on whether vomiting is appropriate and how to do it safely.
Myth #5: Butter, Creams, or Oils Help Burns Heal Faster
The reality: Applying butter or ointments to burns can trap heat and bacteria, worsening the injury. Some substances can also be toxic if your pet licks them.
What to do instead: Flush the burn gently with cool (not cold) water for several minutes and call your vet. Avoid using ice – it can cause further tissue damage.
Myth #6: You Should Splint Broken Bones at Home
The reality: Attempting to splint a fracture yourself can cause more pain or worsen the injury. Poorly applied splints can cut off circulation or put pressure on the wrong spot.
What to do instead: Keep your pet as still and calm as possible and transport them to the vet immediately. If you must move them, use a towel or blanket as a stretcher.
Myth #7: If a Pet Stops Breathing, CPR Is the Same as for Humans
The reality: While pet CPR shares some similarities with human CPR, the ratios, hand placement, and techniques differ for dogs and cats. Using the wrong method could be ineffective – or harmful.
What to do instead: Take a pet first aid and CPR class so you’re prepared to help in an emergency. Many local animal shelters and veterinary clinics offer them.
Myth #8: All First Aid Kits Are the Same
The reality: A human first aid kit won’t meet all your pet’s needs. For example, items like self-adhesive bandages (that won’t stick to fur) and pet-safe antiseptics are essential.
What to do instead: Build a pet-specific first aid kit with your vet’s guidance. Include their medical records, an emergency contact list, and any medications they take regularly.
Myth #9: If a Pet Seems Fine, They Don’t Need to See a Vet
The reality: Some injuries and illnesses aren’t obvious right away. Internal bleeding, organ damage, or slow-acting toxins may not show symptoms until it’s too late.
What to do instead: Always err on the side of caution. Even if your pet appears fine after an accident or health scare, a checkup can catch problems before they become serious.
How to Be Truly Prepared
Now that we’ve debunked these pet first aid myths, the most important takeaway is this: first aid is only the first step. It buys you time until you can get your pet professional care – it’s not a substitute for it.
Here are a few ways to prepare so you can act quickly and safely in an emergency:
- Take a certified pet first aid and CPR course.
- Keep a well-stocked, pet-specific first aid kit in your home and car.
- Post emergency numbers (vet, emergency clinic, poison control) where they’re easy to find.
- Review your pet insurance coverage so you’re not delaying treatment over cost concerns.
Emergencies are stressful, but knowing the right steps – and avoiding the wrong ones – can make all the difference for your pet’s recovery.
Protect Your Pet for the Unexpected
Even the most prepared pet parent can’t prevent every accident or illness. Pet insurance can help you say “yes” to the care your pet needs without the added stress of big vet bills. If you haven’t already, take a moment today to explore coverage options. The best time to prepare for an emergency is before it happens.
Thinking of insuring your pet?
Get Quotes & Compare
References:
https://www.avma.org/resources-tools/pet-owners/emergencycare/first-aid-tips-pet-owners
Disclaimer
The information contained on this blog is intended for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice. It is not a substitute for professional veterinary care. Always consult with your veterinarian before making any changes to your pet's health care or treatment plan.
The authors of this blog are not veterinarians and do not claim to be experts in pet health. The information provided here is based on our own experiences and research, as well as information from reputable sources. However, we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of this information.
We encourage you to do your own research and consult with your veterinarian before making any decisions about your pet's health.
Previous post
Door Dashing Training for DogsNext post
Does Librela Work for Arthritis in DogsCharitable Giving
With every pet insurance policy we generate, we do our bit to help less fortunate animals across Canada and the U.S. by making a donation to one of our chosen animal charities or rescue centres.
Compare top pet insurance providers plans.
Enter your dog’s age in years and months to calculate their age equivalent to human years.
Calculate your dog’s ageEnter your cat’s age in years and months to calculate their age equivalent to human years.
Calculate your cat’s age