Shelter Island Veterinary Hospital

4.6 (84)
3625 Midway Dr Suite T, San Diego, CA 92110, USA


Monday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Tuesday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Wednesday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Thursday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Friday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Saturday: Closed

Sunday: Closed

How to Save Money at Shelter Island Veterinary Hospital

Schedule Regular Vet Visits

One of the best ways to save on vet bills is to prevent expensive health issues before they develop. By scheduling regular wellness checkups, your vet can detect health issues early, helping you to avoid costly treatments and surgeries down the road.

Price Shop for Pet Prescriptions

Oftentimes our fur babies are prescribed human drugs off-label. Your vet is apt to charge more for these medications than you would pay at your local pharmacy. In fact, big-box or chain pharmacies can offer steep discounts. So it’s best to price shop.

Pet Insurance

Most pet insurance providers will pay between 80% and 90% of the vet bill. You can even get coverage for routine care and things like vaccinations and dental cleanings. If you do the math, you’ll most likely find that pet insurance makes financial sense in the long run as well as gives you peace of mind.

How Do You Choose the Right Pet Insurance Provider?

Pet Insurance Review makes it incredibly easy for pet parents to select an insurance provider they feel good about. You can use our handy comparison tool to get the gist of what a company offers. We’ve also collected over 150,000 reviews of insurance companies from real pet parents like you to rank the top providers in the market. Here is the current ranking of each:

Top Pet Insurance Providers of 2024
Rating Provider Total Review
4.4 AKC 889
4.7 ASPCA 11,445
4.9 Embrace 14,311
4.9 Fetch 2,197
4.4 Figo 2,600
4.7 Hartville 164
4.9 Healthy Paws 7,488
4.9 Lemonade 790
3.2 ManyPets 2,173
4.6 MetLife 506
4.8 Nationwide 21,394
4.3 Pet Assure 12
4.7 PetPartners 110
4.5 Pets Best 7,204
4.3 Pumpkin 1,175
4.7 Spot 5,460
4.9 Trupanion 60,328
4.8 Prudent Pet 125

Or, you can simply get a fast quote from multiple providers and go from there.

Thinking of insuring your pet?

Get Quotes & Compare

Getting to Know Your New Vet: Essential Questions to Ask

Choosing a new veterinarian is an important decision for any pet owner. You want to find someone who is competent, compassionate, and a good fit for you and your fur baby. To help you get the most out of your first appointment, here's a list of essential questions to ask your new vet:

Tell me about your experience with [pet type].

Different vets have different areas of specialization. Some are experts with cats, some dogs, some pocket pets, and some horses. Knowing that your vet has vast experience treating your specific type of pet can bring you peace of mind.

How do you handle emergencies?

You must know what to do in case of a pet medical emergency. Inquire what after-hours policy the clinic has, whether they have on-site emergency care available, and if they have a relationship with any nearby emergency animal hospitals.

How do you communicate with pet owners?

Good communication is key to building a trusting relationship with your vet. Ask how they prefer to communicate (phone calls, emails, online portal) and how often you can expect to hear from them.

Are there any breed-specific health concerns I should be aware of?

Some breeds are predisposed to certain health conditions. Knowing what to watch out for can help you catch problems early and get your pet the treatment they need.

Do you have any questions for me about my pet?

This is a great question to ask because the answer will show that the vet is interested in getting to know your pet as an individual and is willing to listen to your concerns.

Bonus question: Can I take a tour of your facility?

Getting a feel for the clinic's environment can help you and your pet feel more comfortable during your visits. Remember, you’re not just looking for a veterinarian, you’re looking for a partnership. Do not be afraid to ask these questions and any others you can think of. Any vet worth their salt will be happy to answer them. Because the more informed you are, the better equipped you'll be to make decisions about your pet's care! And that should be every vet’s top priority.

Reviews from Google

hand swipe
Tony I

I was referred to this Hospital by my regular vet because Dr Darnell is known as an expert in FIP disease. The staff was wonderful with my cat. Dr Darnell made some recommendations, and prescribed some meds, and then asked me to call her with an update on a specific day. I called and she returned my call in a timely manner. We discussed my cats situation and she gave me some direction and asked me to call her again in a couple of day. I'm very happy with the treatment my cat is receiving.

posted: 06/17/2023

Harley Berman

If you're searching for an exceptional veterinarian for your beloved pet, look no further than Shelter Island! I've had the pleasure of working with many vets over the years due to frequent moves, but Dr. Nancy is a uniquely fantastic vet. She has provided the best possible care for my cat Rosilyn, and has treated us both with respect and comfort every step of the way. Dr. Nancy is an outstanding communicator and does an excellent job of explaining what she's doing with your pet. She's incredibly patient, answering all of my questions, and guiding me through every detail of my cat's care. When Rosilyn's X-ray revealed a growth during surgery, Dr. Nancy called me immediately to let me know and even called in a specialist to assist. She then performed surgery to remove the tumor, doing her absolute best given the circumstances. Overall, I cannot recommend Dr. Nancy and Shelter Island enough. She's an incredibly skilled and compassionate veterinarian who truly cares about her patients' well-being. Thank you, Dr. Nancy and Shelter Island Veterinary Hospital, for all that you do!!!

posted: 03/27/2023


Dr. Nancy and the team at SIVH came highly recommended and took such great care of our 10 year old Rexkitty for his teeth cleaning and routine wellness visits. Dr. Nancy provided pre and post procedure education for us with clear guidance throughout the process. I appreciated her providing medication to administer to him prior to visits to help manage his vet-anxiety. Having your fur baby go under for any procedure can be a stressful process and I thank the team for keeping us at ease the entire time. Michelle at the front desk was also extremely helpful in coordinating our cat's care. I highly recommend SIVH!

posted: 07/20/2022


I am so thankful for Dr. Darnell. She is THE BEST. I had previously mentioned to two vets that I believe my cat had serious teeth issues. Both other vets did an oral exam, saw nothing visibly wrong and told me she just needed her teeth cleaned. Dr. Darnell actually listened to my concerns, did x-rays and found major internal cavities that were inside her teeth (not visible when doing a regular exam) that could eventually lead to bone infection and massive bone loss. Turns out my baby also suffers from severe juvenile periodontitis. I am beyond thankful to Dr. Darnell for being such an incredible vet and wonderful person. I would not take my fur babies anywhere else. So, if you're looking for a vet who is talented at what she does, and is passionate about genuinely caring for our fur babies, go see Dr. Darnell of Shelter Island Vet Hospital. You will be very glad you did.

posted: 12/28/2020

Stephanie Stanek

Dr. Darnell is the best vet you will find in the area. She fully listens to your concerns, takes her time with a complete exam of your pet, and clearly articulates information about your pet. She is honest and a good friend to many pet owners in the neighborhood. She ALWAYS has the animals best interest in mind! She goes above and beyond for every single one of her clients. After seeing multiple vets including a 2 week hospitalization for my cat, she was able to get my cat back on track to good health. I only wish I came to her sooner!

posted: 06/28/2022