Pets Best | Pet Insurance Review

4.9

out of 5

Number of reviews 14,149

Founded by veterinarian Dr. Jack Stephens, Pets Best insures cats and dogs in every state and has paid nearly $150 million in claims since 2005. is recommended by veterinarians across the U.S. Learn more about Pets Best plan options, read thousands of customer reviews and get a quote so you can make an informed choice about your pet insurance provider.
3

out of 5

POSTED: | BY: Bill

Nitpickers

As anticipated they nitpicked the invoices and excluded as much as they could make an argument. It seems pretty much like most medical insurance companies that really don't want to pay. We can live with the nitpicking, that was expected but it too countless emails and calls. Regretfully the pandemic the nation was hit with exacerbated an already defined slower process. Final results were ok but if I had not been a pain in their *** I suspect it would be extended for months. I can't say in the end I did not get paid but they tried.
4

out of 5

POSTED: | BY: Tracy Merrill

Price of policy is reasonable

Price of policy is reasonable. Other than the amount of time it takes to process some claims, this insurance company is good.
3

out of 5

POSTED: | BY: Brian

Needs a little improvement

Their prices are very good and you get alot of coverage for your money. Making a claim is very easy but their processing time on a claim is the only downfall. On average it takes about month to process a claim and then get your money.
1

out of 5

POSTED: | BY: Michael Nemeth

DO NOT BUY THIS INSURANCE!

DO NOT BUY THIS INSURANCE! Given my experience, I have to say this is probably the worst insurance agency I've ever dealt with in my life. I have open complains with the BBB and CA Department of Insurance against them, and I'm contemplating litigation at this point since they seem to not give a flying rip about me. This is copied from my Yelp review. You can find supporting pictures and documentation to back up what I'm saying there. My decent into pet insurance hell began on Christmas Eve of 2019, when my dog began vomiting uncontrollably. The vet diagnosed my dog with a possible bowel obstruction and he also noticed a suspicious mass, so my dog underwent an exploratory abdominal surgery and had the mass removed and biopsied. What a Christmas! I don't have a wife or kids, so this dog is like a child to me. My dog's bowels were cleared, but the mass turned out to be an aggressive mast cell cancer. This led to many follow up visits and medications that cost several thousands of dollars. To start off with, Pets Best said it would take them a MONTH before they even bothered to look at my claim. So I had to eat thousands of dollars in medical bills with the expectation that I would possibly get reimbursed over a month from the time they were filed. Well, a month goes by and they finally get around to looking at my claim. I get a nice little rejection letter by email in the middle of the night on a Friday (so I have to wait the entire weekend before I can talk to anyone) telling me that my claim was rejected because my vet wasn't giving them the required medical records. So of course I call my vet and make sure all the appropriate records were sent, then call Pets Best to confirm they got the records - and Pets Best said they did! Yet they continued to reject my claims saying they never got my records! I've called repeatedly both my vet and Pets Best trying to clear this up, same response every time. This nonsense is still going on today! I just got another rejection record for my last claim on 3/2/2020 for the same reason. I still haven't been paid for the initial claim on 12/24/2019! This business is a scam! I've filed complaints with the California Department of Insurance and the Better Business Bureau against them. I'm giving them time to respond to those complaints before I open litigation against them. These people need to be shut down. My claim aside, the way I was treated by them was also outrageous. When they reject your claim, they do so by issuing an automated email, typically in the middle of the night when they know you can't reach anyone, instead of notifying you by phone, so you can't dispute it with them directly. I tried getting the contact information for their VP of claims or the GM and they refused to let me talk to them. When I tried to escalate my issue up the chain of command over the phone, they transferred me to a supervisors voice mail who never bothered to call me back! This place is a joke! ----- Update: So Ali here gets back to me and says they are missing some specific records from a vet I visited back in 2018. None of the other customer service agents I talked to ever mentioned this to me. This is the first I've heard of it! I asked SEVERAL customer service agents REPEATEDLY if there was anything missing and I was told NO! I had to post a public Yelp review before they bothered to tell me what they were even looking for! So here we go again! I called my old vet and they said they don't have the records that Pets Best is looking for. My old vet said they faxed over all the records they have on file, so now my old vet has to try and figure out a way to amend finalized notes from years ago to satisfy Pets Best. This is crazy. ----- Update: Their Assistant VP of sales just got back to me after I filed all of these complaints and went public with my problems. She has assured me that she is personally looking into the case and will work with my vets to get the information they need. Hallelujah! The question you have to ask yourself is, why didn't they work with my vets to get this resolved in the first place?! Why didn't they tell me specifically what records they were looking for when I called the last several times? Why do they send automated rejection letters instead of hold notices that explain exactly what information they feel is missing? While I'm supremely grateful that I finally have senior management looking into my case, I have to question what kind of operation they are running over there. ----- Update: You're not going to believe this one! They finally finished reviewing my case. They claimed the exploratory abdominal for the suspected bowel obstruction... was wait for it... DENIED - BECAUSE THEY SAID IT WAS ACTUALLY A SURGERY FOR A PRE-EXISTING LIVER CONDITION!!!!!! - No, I'm not joking. I swear, check out the photo! I really need to sue these people. These people are disgusting.
5

out of 5

POSTED: | BY: John Snyder

Highly satisfied customer!!

Our rescue Greyhound was admitted to the hospital for two days after a sick visit to our Vet. Over the two day period she incurred a great deal of cost. Pets Best processed our claim in an accurate and timely manner, which was very impressive considering our dogs illness occurred in the middle of the covid-19 outbreak and lock down within many states. We initially selected this company due to their stellar reputation and fair pricing. In addition, they provide value added services and their customer service is second to none.Words cannot express how satisfied we are in dealing with the company. We highly recommend them.

Monthly Cost

$6 and up, depending on your chosen plan.

Coverage

Accident and Illness plans with optional reimbursement levels of 70%, 80%, or 90% after the deductible. Flat Rate Accident coverage for $9/month for dogs and $6/month for cats. (Available in most states). Two optional Wellness plans to cover routine care. 24/7 Pet Helpline, powered by whiskerDocs is included on all policies. The pay-out amount is based on your actual vet bill. Reimbursements are sent directly to CareCredit credit card when chosen as your default reimbursement method. Choose to have your eligible claim payment reimbursed directly back to your CareCredit card.

Payout Limits

$5000 -Unlimited annual limit, depending on your chosen plan. Unlimited lifetime limits.

Deductible

$50 – $1,000 annually.

Age Limits

Pet must be at least 7 weeks old to enroll. Pets Best does not restrict coverage or availability for older pets.

Waiting Period

A waiting period refers to the amount of time after enrolling before your pet is eligible for coverage. Waiting periods vary by the type of coverage and start on the effective date of your policy. Once met, waiting periods are waived for continuous, uninterrupted policy renewals. Pets Best offers some of the shortest waiting periods in the industry following the policy effective date. Get a quote for specific information on waiting periods in your state.

Exclusions

Pre-existing conditions are not covered. Elective and preventive procedures are not covered.

Disclosures

Waiting periods, annual deductible, co-insurance, benefit limits, and exclusions may apply. For all terms visit www.petsbest.com/policy. Products, schedules, discounts, and rates may vary and are subject to change. Premiums are based on and may increase or decrease due to the age of your pet, the species or breed of your pet, and your home address.

Pet insurance coverage offered and administered by Pets Best Insurance Services, LLC is underwritten by American Pet Insurance Company (NAIC #12190), a New York insurance company headquartered at 6100 4th Ave. S. Suite 200 Seattle, WA 98108, or Independence American Insurance Company (NAIC #26581), a Delaware insurance company located at 11333 N. Scottsdale Rd. Ste. 160 Scottsdale, AZ 85254 or MS Transverse Insurance Company (NAIC #21075), located at 15 Independence Blvd. Suite 430, Warren, NJ 07059. Pets Best Insurance Services, LLC (NPN #8889658, CA agency #0F37530) is a licensed insurance agency located at 11333 N. Scottsdale Rd. #160 Scottsdale, AZ 85254. Each insurer has sole financial responsibility for its own products. Please refer to your declarations page to determine the underwriter for your policy. Terms and conditions apply. See your policy for details.

Pets Best was founded by veterinarian Dr. Jack Stephens, whose passion for saving pets led him on a mission to provide access to comprehensive, yet affordable, animal healthcare. Pets Best offers pet insurance for dogs and cats in every state and has paid nearly $150 million in claims since 2005. Pets Best is rated 9.6 out of 10 (TrustPilot) and is recommended by veterinarians across the U.S. Built upon a legacy of innovation, it focuses on putting customers first by offering unlimited accident and illness plans, wellness plans, a mobile app, a 24/7 Pet Helpline (powered by whiskerDocs), and more.

Get a quote today

Leave a review