ASPCA | Pet Insurance Review

I have had my dog, Stella, insured with ASPCA since I got her in 2012. On 10/19/18 I decided to upgrade my coverage to a newly filed and available plan. I recently filed a claim for Stella for a dental infection. She was also treated for dental infection back in 2017. The company has denied my claim, stating that my original coverage was cancelled on 10/19/18 and new coverage began on 10/20/18. After being a loyal customer with uninterrupted coverage for over 12 years, they are using this as a loophole to deny coverage. And of course at Stella’s age, I can’t really move her to another insurer. Beyond unethical and so disappointing.

DO NOT sign up with this pet insurance policy company. They have denied my dog coverage of a cardiac condition he developed as a result of his advanced age - 17 - claiming that it is excluded as a “congenital” disease. My vet wrote a letter in support explaining that my dog contracted mitral valve disease due to age-related circumstances and that it was never an issue before this, that no records in any exam indicated any cardiac issues in the past 16 years. Still, they denied coverage making this bogus claim. I’ve been a customer for 17 years and have paid well over thousands of dollars through the years, just for them to deny this??? My dog has hardly ever been ill before this incident. I am appalled at this company and would STRONGLY advise you to look elsewhere for your pet’s health insurance needs.

This is a racket, don't do it! Put aside the amount of money you would spend on this pet insurance into a different account. I have paid close to 30K to ASPCA Pet Health Insurance over 14 years and have only been reimbursed $3809. Kept telling myself it was "peace of mind". You are way better off setting up a bank account. You could rescue and help hundreds of animals with the money you would save!

Have used for over 10 years. Noted improvements in the app and customer service. Banfield clinic closed so looking to add preventative luckily did so because one cat somehow wasn’t added with initial service and preventive services could begin immediately! Only complaint is that cannot add on or change plans except at annual renewal cycle and those cannot be prorated or changed to coincide with annual vet appointments. So although Cat added with prevention, I have to wait another four months before I can add the others!

This is the worst pet insurance I ever had. Their billing dept is incompetent! My previous company stopped selling pet insurance. Choosing ASPCA was a mistake. I cancelled when one pet died and canceled the other one in January 2025. They have just drafted my account for both pets yet again even though one died in Sept 2024. I will spend another 30 minutes on the phone today trying to get them to understand! Uggg