Best Pet Insurance in Wisconsin 2025

Pet insurance in Wisconsin is surprisingly affordable, and it helps to ensure that if the worst should happen, your furry friend can get the treatment they need.

 

Posted: 01/13/2025

Why Pet Insurance in Wisconsin is Important

In the picturesque state of Wisconsin, pets are an integral part of our families, providing boundless joy and companionship.
Get a free pet insurance quotes and find the best plan for your pets.
But, with 1 out of 3 pets needing emergency vet care in their lifetime, many pet parents live with constant stress, wondering if they can afford treatment should something happen. And that’s where pet insurance becomes crucial. Pet insurance in Wisconsin is surprisingly affordable and helps ensure your fur baby gets the care they need should an unexpected accident or illness occur.

How to Choose the Best Pet Insurance in Wisconsin

Vet bills are expensive, and 80% of pet parents say they could not afford a $5,000 vet bill if the worst happened. Having pet insurance in Wisconsin is the best way to protect your pet against injury, illness, and other emergencies. With some plans paying up to 90% of the vet bills, insuring your pet is one of the most important investments you can make. 

But how do you choose a pet insurance policy that’s right for you? That’s where we come in. Pet Insurance Review is an unbiased source of information to help you make the best financial decision for your family. We compare prices from pet insurance providers across the state that have proven track records for quality coverage and a willingness to stand by pet parents when they need help. 

But perhaps even more important, we have collected over 150,000 honest reviews of pet insurance providers from pet parents just like you. We use these reviews to rank the top companies in the marketplace. This makes it incredibly easy to find a reputable company with a proven track record of exceptional customer service.

Top Pet Insurance Providers of 2025 in Wisconsin
Rating Provider Total Review
4.4 AKC 894
4.5 ASPCA 12,057
4.9 Embrace 20,303
4.9 Fetch 27,407
4.1 Figo 2,785
4.5 Hartville 177
4.9 Healthy Paws 10,731
4.8 Lemonade 815
4.6 ManyPets 2,428
4.6 MetLife 5,626
4.8 Nationwide 21,417
3.9 Pet Assure 15
4.4 PetPartners 117
4.3 Pets Best 14,111
4.7 Pumpkin 2,544
4.6 Spot 9,851
4.8 Trupanion 62,910
4.8 Prudent Pet 2,443

How Much is Pet Insurance in Wisconsin?

Cost of pet insurance coverage in Wisconsin will vary based on a few different factors. Your specific location and zip code definitely comes into play. Those pet parents residing in a big city in Wisconsin will likely pay more than those in a smaller, rural area. 

The age of your pet will also impact your monthly premiums. Like older people, older pets tend to have more health issues that require more medical care. That’s why it’s always a good idea to enroll your fur baby when they are young and healthy as you’ll get the lowest rate possible.

And finally, your fur baby’s breed and species will also impact price. Dogs will usually cost a bit more than cats to insure, and certain breeds of dog with certain hereditary conditions may cost even more.

To give you a general idea of how much it costs to insure dogs and cats in Wisconsin, take a look at the following charts:

Most popular dog breeds insured in Wisconsin
Breed Average Monthly Cost
Other Mixed Breed $35.34
Beagle $65.07
Goldendoodle $0.00
Bichon Frise $21.71
Yorkshire Terrier $0.00
Labrador Retriever (Black) $0.00
German Shepherd $0.00
Dalmatian $0.00
Data source date 60 days, based on user selected percentage
Most popular cat breeds insured in Wisconsin
Breed Average Monthly Cost
Other Mixed Breed $0.00
Domestic Short Hair $41.42
American Shorthair $55.47
Data source date 60 days, based on user selected percentage

The best pet insurance in Wisconsin really comes down to a policy you can comfortably afford with a provider who has a history of taking excellent care of their customers. We hope to help you find just that!

Our Pet Parents reviews

hand swipe
5

out of 5

Friendly vets who really care!

Had a great experience with My Best Friend Veterinary Center (https://www.mybestfriendvet.com/ ). The team is super friendly, patient, and clearly loves what they do. They take time to explain everything and make sure pets feel comfortable. If you’re looking for a vet who truly treats your pet like...

5

out of 5

Jordy’s stomach issue

Jordy started throwing up daily, I took him to our local clinic, they took X-rays. He was referred to Nelson’s Veterinary Clinic to be further examined by Dr. T. Taylor. Jordy was diagnosed with an obstruction inside his stomach at rectum. He had surgery the next day. A growth was removed and sent f...

5

out of 5

Amber

Amber is the best . She is super awesome and has my loyalty. She’s so good to the point where I had to inform my Vet about her and the services she provide. She really cares about the kiddos and mines. She gave great advice to me about my kiddos. I was given another quote by Chewy when I spoke with...

5

out of 5

Timely and Reliable

During the first two years of our dog’s young, active life, he’s had a series of mishaps. Fetch has always paid promptly and reliably. We just adopted a shelter cat, and I’ve had such a great experience with them that I’ve covers him too. They did increase our rate for a year, but then actually just...

5

out of 5

Can't recommend Figo Pet Insurance enough!

I can’t say enough good things about Figo Pet Insurance. When I got my kitten, I honestly didn’t think I’d need insurance—she was only 8 months old, and friends even told me it would just be a waste of money. But life happens, and sure enough, my sweet kitten ended up injuring herself. I was so r...

5

out of 5

Hartville Really Helped!

We have multiple cats and each have coverage through Hartville. When our sweet Millie had an emergency vet visit due to complications with her FeLV diagnosis, Hartville swiftly processed the claim and provided the reimbursement we needed. I’ve had other pet insurance before and Hartville is the only...

5

out of 5

The best insurance

Healthy Paws has saved my life multiple times. I have four pets, all insured with them, and I’ve already used the coverage three times. Every experience has been fast and easy. As long as you submit all the documents they ask for, the reimbursement comes within just a few days. I always recommend t...

5

out of 5

Thank you for your service

Always easy to claim my insecurities , takes about few minutes to fill up all the questions . Never had any problems getting my money back. Money is returned within a couple of minutes. Thank you for your service!

5

out of 5

Many pets

Many pets insurance was great. But they pulled out of the us market and yea agreed us to Odie which is terrible

5

out of 5

Best service!

I was given the best customer service by Kieth and he was very straightforward with helping me understand the policy I have better! Very professional and efficient customer service! I would recommend this insurance to anyone with a pet! They have helped me so much with making sure my cat is getting...

5

out of 5

Nationwide Pet Insurance has excellent customer service

I have had Nationwide Pet Insurance for over 10 years, and I have never had any issue. They have an easy to use website to open new claims and review the status of all claims. I have used the vet line for questions about issues with my dogs. My dogs are my family, and I would not work with a comp...

5

out of 5

Are you searching for parrots for sale in the UK

Are you searching for parrots for sale in the UK? Whether you're dreaming of a vibrant Blue and Gold Macaw, a charming African Grey, or a playful Amazon parrot, your perfect feathered companion is just a few clicks away. At Parrot Patch, we offer healthy, hand-reared parrots that are friendly, talka...

5

out of 5

Arshy Torres

Excelente!!!

5

out of 5

Repeated Bouts of Pneumonia

I am constantly recommending Pets Best to my friends and family who are pet owners or are considering becoming pet owners. Nearly eight months ago, I had to rush my dog to the emergency room because he was struggling to breathe. He was diagnosed with aspiration pneumonia and had to stay in the ho...

5

out of 5

Covered dog's emergency visit and TPLO surgery due to injury/CCL tear

We are lucky we signed up for pumpkin. We talked about it for a while and never did and then decided to right before a trip and an annual checkup with the vet. That week, our dog went to jump on the bed and tore her right CCL and needed TPLO. Had to send pumpkin a million documents from her vet visi...

5

out of 5

Technology and Ships

Venture into the breathtaking realm of EVE Online. Become a legend today. Build alongside hundreds of thousands of explorers worldwide. Play for free

5

out of 5

Trupanion

The vets at Garden State take Trupanion as payment, all we had to lay out was the 10 percent. My dog had cancer and had treatment for over a year. They payed out over 65,000. Cancer finally took her. We have a new dog now and she is insured by Trupanion.

5

out of 5

Without a doubt…

Without a doubt, the best pet insurance one should buy for their loved one (pet). The quality of service and customer care is bar none; and the assurance that they will ease the burden in those critical imes of need, is truly what convinced me that Prudent Pet is my choice ! Thanks

Get a quote today

Leave a review