Price Satisfaction

Discover whether pet owners feel they’re getting good value from their pet insurance plans. These reviews focus on pricing transparency, affordability, and overall satisfaction with plan costs.

23,540 total


September 23, 2025

Bad business practices

We received a notice that our 24hour Pet Watch was transferred to Hartville - they downgraded our coverage and tripled our monthly premium for the two cats from $137 to $392. There is no account information, no way to see details. We received no notice prior to this email. We can’t even cancel the insurance. That this is legal in the US speaks leagues to why everyone is so pissed off. Businesses are run poorly and they cover their lack of management ability by treating their customers poorly, overcharging while failing to provide value and engaging in other unscrupulous behavior.

Insurer: Hartville

Veterinarian: Belle Haven Animal Medical Centre

By: Melanie

Useful
September 23, 2025

Worth it to have the little guy covered

I like that there are yearly reimbursements for wellness appointments, vaccines, dental cleanings, etc. Payouts are quick and I'm glad we have our little guy covered.

Insurer: Spot

By: Hannah Allen

September 22, 2025

This was easy and what I like is that…

This was easy and what I like is that it covers both of my pets and I don't have to get multiple policies for each pet!

Insurer: Prudent Pet

By: Tracey Ninivaggi

September 22, 2025

I thought I would get more reimbursed.

I thought I would get more reimbursed.

Insurer: Spot

By: Toni Martindale

September 22, 2025

I have had metLife pet insurance now…

I have had metLife pet insurance now for some 7 years / two different dogs and it has been very worthwhile - but will say when i first subscribed it was for catostrophic purpose and was $35 a month i am now more than triple this cost for same coverage and a deductible of $250 -for 5k - I do think it has gotten pricey - and hoping that the renewal isn't double this year what i pay now because i will have to seek other companies -

Insurer: MetLife

By: Valued Customer

September 22, 2025

French Bulldog parent, Happy Customer

We purchased our policy for our French Bulldog when he was 6 weeks- or so- of age and we had it until he passed away. The terms of our policy were easy to understand. When I called for clarification about a claim- the customer service representative was helpful and knowledgeable. 9 times out our 10- the app was easy to use to submit claims and check on their status. The text alerts were very helpful and welcomed. Email communication of the claim processing was also helpful. We appreciated the email from PetsBest when our little guy passed away unexpectedly. I have found Pets Best so easy to work with and so reasonable- that I recommended them to a new French Bulldog parent that I met in the pet store. She was not aware of the need for pet insurance when becoming a French Bulldog parent. Our experience has been so good- that I also recommended Pets Best to a coworker who was wanting to purchase insurance- as a gift- to her daughter for her new mixed breed puppy. Thank you, Pets Best for being so easy to work with for the past 4.5 years- it was a nice, unexpected, surprise.

Insurer: Pets Best

By: Holly R

September 21, 2025

Consider an Alternative

Rates have gone up twice in less than two years, and the coverage is abysmal. $50 coverage for a $130 checkup?? I've been paying $80 a month for almost two years now and am seriously considering switching.

Insurer: Spot

By: Anthony Scerri

September 21, 2025

Great experience

Great experience. Payment quick and easy. Very pleased with this company

Insurer: Pumpkin

By: Michele Lacina

September 20, 2025

Dog insurance made easy

The claims process is easy and the prices are comparable to others. I have had no issues.

Insurer: Spot

By: Gigetta Spear

September 20, 2025

My question was never answered as to…

My question was never answered as to how do I report visits to Pumpkin for reimbursement. Maybe if someone would contact me with an answer I could give a better rating. If not, I’ll be cancelling with Pumpkin and looking elsewhere for pet insurance. The amount I’m paying in insurance monthly would be better used as savings for when my boys need to visit the vet.

Insurer: Pumpkin

By: Wendy

Compare top pet insurance providers plans.

For puppies and kittens, please estimate your pet's full-grown weight.