I have been trying to decide between Petplan and Healthy Paws for my Papillon puppy. Both have comparable coverage, with PP being slightly better because it pays for more dental conditions and non-routine vet exam fees. Both also have generally good reputations. As far as rates, it gets tricky. Initial rates for the puppy were $37 for PP and $46 for HP. I almost bought PP but I thought I'd take a look at what the rates might be as the dog got older. It ends up that at 3 years, the current PP rate is $54, HP is $61 (90% and $250 deductible). But at 5 years, PP goes up to $84, HP is only $75. Then at 7 years, PP is $106, HP is $78 (both plans reduced to 80% coverage). At 10 years, PP is $92, HP is $63 (both plans reduced to 60%/$750 deductible). Bottom line is that PP was cheaper for the first 3-4 years, but then HP became cheaper. I've decided to go with HP, but everyone should make their own decision. I'm only giving folks something to consider.